Celtic Heroes

Our biggest challenge is keeping our members interested. After 4 years of the same old things, the game is at its lowest ineterest level. Even those who spend $300-400 on plat every month have stopped. When you get disappointed day after day from crappy boss raid drops, camping for several every day for nothing, can't say I blame them.

The game now mostly exist in Messaging apps. A lot of our members spend more time chatting outside the game, it's the bond as clan members have established over the years that kept some from totally quitting.

I agree totally. I've spent hundreds and hundreds of dollars on this game, to a point where Ive built 4 characters and I don't enjoy it as much as I use too. The repetitive nature of the game can be tedious. Taken as a whole, it's hard to get excited about building a new character when you know you have to repeat quest lines and endure the Frozen Quest one more time. After the Frozen orb quest endurance challenge, you have dragon lord, and exalted dragon lord Quests that are exceedingly hard unless you have a strong Clan to back you up. Even in the instance when you have a strong Clan, you have to compete within the Clan to get the drops you need inorder to complete your armor set.
After your clan gears you up , you get the feeling like every time you log in, if you don't instantly respond to every boss call, you've betrayed your clan. The real golden lining is I get to chat with other players that have been enduring the same.
There's an unsaid, but blatantly obvious thing that everybody has to deal with. The player you recruit to your clan today, is the same one you have to compete with in a few weeks for your frozen, DL, edl Quest items.
The creators of this game have mastered the Makavelin approach.....Kudos!!!! I can't imagine a better orchestrated dynamic created in the electronic online game age.